"Just finish it" is the most expensive sentence in sheet-metal sourcing. Anodize, powder coat and plating protect against different things, scale differently at small batches, and interact with your dimensions in ways that decide whether the enclosure actually closes. The finish is also the last process your part sees and the first thing your customer judges. Here's how the three compare for parts made in China, and how to call the right one on the drawing.
What each finish actually is
- Anodize (aluminum only) — an electrochemically grown oxide layer, typically 5–25 μm. It's part of the metal, not a layer on it: hard, thin, dimensionally honest. Type II is the general decorative/corrosion grade; Type III (hard anodize) goes 25–80+ μm for wear surfaces.
- Powder coat — electrostatically applied polymer, cured in an oven, typically 60–100 μm. A thick, tough, colored skin. The workhorse finish for steel and aluminum enclosures alike, and the one finish Chinese sheet-metal shops most often run in-house.
- Plating (steel parts) — usually zinc, 5–25 μm, with a passivation top (clear/blue, yellow, black). Thin enough to keep threads and dimensions live; it's corrosion protection and conductivity, not cosmetics.
The environment decides the base layer
- Indoor, dry, cosmetic: any of them work — pick by look and cost. For steel, zinc plate with clear passivation is the cheapest honest protection; powder if color matters.
- Outdoor or humid: powder coat on steel (the passivation layer alone will rust eventually); anodize or powder on aluminum. Coastal or industrial atmospheres push film thickness up — this is not the place to save 20 μm.
- Electrical contact, grounding, EMI: conductivity kills powder (60–100 μm of polymer is an insulator). Zinc plating or chem-film (Alodine) on contact areas — or mask the powder off them.
- Wear, sliding, abrasion: hard anodize on aluminum; on steel, plating won't save a wear face — design one or add a bushing.
How cost behaves at small batches
This is where buyers get surprised, and the three finishes behave completely differently:
- Powder coat in-house (the shops I work with run their own line) — priced per part or per hanging point; even 30 parts are fine. This is the small-batch friend. An outsourced powder line adds trucking, a day of schedule, and a minimum lot charge divided by your 40 parts.
- Anodize — almost always outsourced, billed by area with a minimum lot charge. Small aluminum batches carry a visible per-part premium; two anodize colors on one order can double the effective minimum.
- Zinc plating — barrel-plated by the kilogram, so small steel parts are cheap; large fabricated panels get racked and priced more like area. Minimums exist but are usually mild.
Practical rule: steel + small batch leans plating or in-house powder; aluminum + small batch leans in-house powder over anodize, unless the part genuinely needs anodize's thinness or Type III hardness.
The details that decide fit
Most "the coating ruined my part" problems are drawing problems. Four callouts to write before the RFQ:
- Masking. Threads, sliding faces, datum faces, grounding points, press-fit bores — name what stays bare. Powder adds 60–100 μm per surface; a coated hole shrinks ~120–200 μm in diameter. On sheet metal, that's the difference between an M4 screw going in and not.
- Thickness by face. Cosmetic faces and functional faces can need different specs; say which is which instead of "60–100 μm everywhere".
- Edge coverage. Powder pulls back on sharp edges; specify the edge break on the drawing (the DFM checklist covers radii) and the coat will actually protect the corners where rust starts.
- Color with a code. RAL for powder, sample panel for anodize. "Black" spans thirty blacks, and anodize dye batches drift between lots — approve a panel, keep it as the standard.
Failure modes worth knowing
- Powder on poor pretreatment — the coating looks perfect and lifts in sheets after a season outdoors. Pretreatment (degrease, phosphate/chromate, dry) matters more than the powder itself; ask what line the shop runs and whether they do adhesion cross-hatch tests.
- Anodize on the wrong alloy — high-silicon castings anodize blotchy (see the ADC12 vs A380 guide); even 5052 vs 6061 sheet takes dye slightly differently. Specify alloy and finish together, not separately.
- White rust on zinc plate — appears within days in humid containers if passivation and drying were sloppy. It's a process-control signal, not fate: insist on passivated, dried, packed parts.
- Galvanic pairs — aluminum fastened with bare steel, or plated brackets on anodized frames with moisture in between. Finish choice includes the fastener plan.
For parts with a real corrosion duty — outdoor enclosures, marine-adjacent gear, anything under warranty terms — add one more line to the RFQ: salt-spray hours per a defined standard (for example 500 h neutral salt spray on powder-coated steel, checked per the relevant ISO/ASTM method). The test costs little per batch and converts "the finish looks good" into a number a factory can be held to. Shops with a real powder line run these checks routinely; shops that can't produce the report are telling you where their process control ends.
A worked example: one enclosure, two finishes
A 1.5 mm SECC electrical enclosure, indoor-instrument duty, 80 pieces. The naive call is "black finish" — and the quotes scatter. The engineered call: body and door in RAL 9005 powder, 60–80 μm, with the grounding studs and hinge pins masked; internal mounting plate sent zinc-plated and bare. Result: the powder runs on the shop's in-house line (no outsourced minimum), the plate plating costs pennies in barrel work, threads stay clean, and the ground path conducts. Same parts, same order — the split finish actually came out cheaper than powder-everything, because masking the plate's features would have cost more than plating it. That's the level this decision lives at: per-face, not per-part.
Questions to ask the finishing line
- Is powder in-house or outsourced? In-house means schedule control and no minimum-lot surprises; outsourced means someone else's queue between your parts and shipment.
- What pretreatment runs before powder? Degrease + phosphate (steel) or chromate (aluminum), and does the line do cross-hatch adhesion tests? Coating quality is decided before the gun fires.
- How is thickness verified? Gauge readings on actual parts, recorded — not "we set the gun".
- Can you hold a retained sample panel? For any colored finish, the approved panel is the contract between orders.
A compact decision table
- Steel enclosure, outdoor, colored: powder coat 60–100 μm, mask threads and grounds.
- Steel bracket, indoor, functional: zinc plate + clear passivation, done.
- Aluminum chassis, indoor, thin and conductive: chem-film, or anodize with masked contact areas.
- Aluminum panel, cosmetic indoor: Type II anodize, natural or dyed, approved sample panel.
- Aluminum wear face: Type III hard anodize 40 μm+.
- Anything coastal: the thickest sensible powder, and stainless fasteners.
Where I fit in
Finish calls are where my 13 years across the four processes pay off fastest: I match the finish to the environment and the batch size, keep the work in shops where powder runs in-house (no minimum-lot surprises), and check the masking map and thickness spec before the RFQ leaves. The finish arrives as specified — and the enclosure closes.
See the sheet-metal floor — powder line in-house →
Sheet metal in China: the full capability guide →
Small batches? How finishing cost behaves at 30–300 pieces →
Send a drawing — finish spec reviewed free →
Common questions
- Can you powder coat aluminum? Yes — it's often the better choice than anodize for outdoor aluminum at small batches: cheaper per area, better barrier, any color. Anodize wins when you need thinness, conductivity (masked), or Type III hardness.
- How thick is powder coat really? Spec 60–100 μm typical; shops can hold less on tight areas and more on corners. Measure with a magnetic/eddy-current gauge at first article — "looks thick" is not a measurement.
- Why does my anodize color differ between orders? Dye baths age and alloys respond differently — 6061 and 5052 never match exactly. The fix is a retained approved sample and one alloy per color, not a better supplier promise.